War is hell! This often repeated statement is thought to have originated in a speech given by General Sherman during the Civil War. War IS hell, but is it also a time to ponder enacting a Federal property tax? Well it was in at least two instances.
In 1798 we had an “Undeclared War with France” after they captured hundreds of US merchant vessels. In an effort to fund the “war” Congress passed a national property tax. Property was divided into three categories: houses over $100, land and houses under $100, and slaves. Assessors in each of the 16 states were authorized to carry out the property tax. Values were established, taxes were collected and the war ended in 1800 (yes, contrary to what you might think we are no longer at war with France).
In 1943, three economists, commissioned by the Treasury Committee on Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations, wrote a proposal to modernize property taxation. They recommended dozens of reforms to centralize and standardize property assessment at a Federal level.
World War II had changed people’s opinions on taxation. People, in general, were motivated to contribute to the war effort at all levels. The Revenue Act of 1942 forced most workers to pay income tax for the first time and still opinion polls consistently showed 85-90% of people thought the new taxes were fair. Property taxes weren’t quite as popular, though, because they didn’t go directly to the war effort. This, coupled with overwhelming disagreements in Congress, killed the idea of a Federal property tax. War is not the best solution. A Federal property tax probably isn’t either.